
liskuntreat
open dms
- May 1, 2025
- 23
Nothing inherently bad about it, this is a safe zone, I'm just curious about this, this is an anonymous vote
⚠️ UK Access Block Notice: Beginning July 1, 2025, this site will no longer be accessible from the United Kingdom. This is a voluntary decision made by the site's administrators. We were not forced or ordered to implement this block. If you're located in the UK, we recommend using a VPN to maintain access.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure BMI is discredited but it somehow still gets referenced and even if not directly referenced, people still use the relative weights to classify people as overweight anyway.BMI 27 so technically overweight but isn't it pretty much entirely discredited these days given males and females of the same height and weight are the same BMI? I can guarantee all women my height and weight look a lot fatter than I do despite that number being the same. I'm pretty normal looking size where I live.
All bulk no cut!!!I put on some weight over Christmas or New Year that I didn't really care to lose. It's the same thing every year. Start eating cake during Christmas and New Year. Then lose the weight for the summer. This year I haven't really much cared about it. If I want to though, I can lose weight really fast.
Absolutely. The height/weight standars are ridiculous. I'm short and I weigh more than most people would think but I was considered over weight when I was working out for hours every day. LolBMI is a bunch of crap that was arbitrarily created. It doesn't take into account large bone structure or muscular development. I'm 5' 11" and weigh about 183 lbs. I used to work out a lot way, way back in the day. Because of that I have fairly large thighs, arms, and back muscles. The stupid guidelines for BMI put me at slightly overweight.
Honestly, people, being obese or overweight doesn't mean you're automatically unhealthy and should lose weight. More emphasis should be given to a blood test that tells how much fat/sugar/sodium/cholesterol/triglycerides you have inside you, as well as other conditions that may affect how much is too much/too little.
BMI is about body MASS. That mass may be fat, may be muscle, may even be water! It just says "you wide" or "you thin", no more, no less.
I'm not fat but I have fat in the good place