• ⚠️ UK Access Block Notice: Beginning July 1, 2025, this site will no longer be accessible from the United Kingdom. This is a voluntary decision made by the site's administrators. We were not forced or ordered to implement this block.

M

MapleS

survived
May 22, 2025
118
Why hanging is considered a violent method?

Hanging done correct way is LITERALLY painless. Even done wrong it's the least paifull method I know
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Emerita, Nihilisticstatic, DoomedDarkCircles and 5 others
OnMyLast Legs

OnMyLast Legs

Too many regrets
Oct 29, 2024
563
I just played around with it a little and didn't get "exploding head" at all. I think I might be able to pull it off soon.
 
  • Hugs
Reactions: monetpompo and MapleS
rainatthebusstop

rainatthebusstop

Student
Aug 20, 2025
110
Because it invokes the imagery of lynchings and hangings, both execution methods that where the same principle but designed to inflict a good couple minutes of pain and struggle for the audience.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Reactions: Nihilisticstatic, Lampost505!, ladylazarus4 and 2 others
M

MapleS

survived
May 22, 2025
118
Because it invokes the imagery of lynchings and hangings, both execution methods that where the same principle but designed to inflict a good couple minutes of pain and struggle for the audience.
What's wrong with a couple minutes of pain and struggling? Like it's not that bad. Poisoning is much worse
 
NonEssential

NonEssential

Hanging in there
Jan 15, 2025
534
Guess it means how one defines violent, a shotgun to the head whilst (probably) painless is called violent due to how gory it is.
Maybe some call it that because hanging corpses look horrifying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nihilisticstatic, gunmetalblue11 and Lampost505!
rainatthebusstop

rainatthebusstop

Student
Aug 20, 2025
110
What's wrong with a couple minutes of pain and struggling? Like it's not that bad. Poisoning is much worse
The label "violent suicide" is for the onlooker, not the person commiting it. If done correctly, you'd pass out long before asphixiating completly, it's just a shocking sight for the person finding your corpse.

Also Poisoning can be rather peaceful if you pick your poison and sedative correctly
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nihilisticstatic, monetpompo, DoomedDarkCircles and 2 others
pharma

pharma

Member
Mar 4, 2023
85
It is, imo. I've seen a couple of videos of it, and usually the body jerks wildly. Not sure how it feels for the hanging person, but that imagery is terrifying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lampost505! and OnMyLast Legs
F

Forveleth

I knew I forgot to do something when I was 15...
Mar 26, 2024
3,066
It is, imo. I've seen a couple of videos of it, and usually the body jerks wildly. Not sure how it feels for the hanging person, but that imagery is terrifying.
This is a normal reaction of an oxygen-starved brain. Usually when the person is to the point they are shaking/jerking they are unconscious and completely unaware of what is going on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Terrible_Life and Nihilisticstatic
voirpoet.

voirpoet.

Member
May 14, 2024
27
Why hanging is considered a violent method?

Hanging done correct way is LITERALLY painless. Even done wrong it's the least paifull method I know
all methods are technically violent because it involves dying
 
ladylazarus4

ladylazarus4

exhausted
May 12, 2024
273
all methods are technically violent because it involves dying
Technically true, but we would not really consider Nembutal, for example, to be violent. Semantics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nihilisticstatic
R

rs929

Warlock
Dec 18, 2020
748
Technically true, but we would not really consider Nembutal, for example, to be violent. Semantics.
Maybe not painful but killing a human being sounds violent by definition
 
  • Like
Reactions: ladylazarus4
Nihilisticstatic

Nihilisticstatic

Static
Aug 6, 2023
59
Historic aspect and its association to "violence" (execution method), the gore (marks, body reacting or struggling) and the fact its more physical way to die compared to more chemical ways that arent immediately associates to suicide and where there isnt an exterior force (rope) at play.
 
N

Nightfoot

Mage
Aug 7, 2025
552
I think it's because some sort of ligature is squeezing your neck hard enough to close off your arteries. Many who survive have marks on their necks where the ligature dug into the neck. Done properly, it's a blood choke. Done improperly, it's strangulation.
 
Pale_Rider

Pale_Rider

Enlightened
Apr 21, 2025
1,457
You don't see many correct long drop hangings by the novice. All strangulation.
 
B

bitterToad

Member
Sep 27, 2025
27
For me, personally:

I have a deep fear that it won't be painless or controlled. That I will get something wrong, or not anticipate something, and end up with my last moments being maddening. Rationally I know that shouldn't matter - assuming I botch it completely, even thirty minutes to an hour of intense suffering will pass and I'll be free. But it does matter to me on an animal level, it terrifies me, like drowning and self-immolation.

I watched a bunch of videos to prepare for it and most of them don't look peaceful, I know that doesn't mean that they aren't. Appearances are deceiving, you could be moving but be out cold, or appear asleep but in extreme pain. And you never really know how many of these videos are legit.

One guy, who appeared to be busy with auto-erotic asphyxiation, looked - not necessarily peaceful - but it happened before he even realized it, and that counts as peaceful to me. That was partial.

Another guy, deliberately did full, he didn't struggle at all. It looks like he eased himself into the loop to the point of black-out so he was already out when he dropped.

All the others looked painful to me though, even if I can argue rationally that they shouldn't be.

I know, according to new and old studies I found, that it should be very quick and painless. Insane pressure cuts off the blood flow to your brain (which I know feels good) and you should black out quickly, but I've not tested the blacking out enough to trust it and it requires specific conditions to test.

All DIY exits carry risk because you don't have people assisting you to make sure everything goes to plan. Even professional executions were historically, and are still today, a variable experience - they always end in fatality, but the process to it varies. Professional euthanasia is best, but you need to live in specific countries to access that. You can recreate it at home if you live in a country were you have easy-enough access to certain chemicals, but you need to be damn sure you know what you're doing.

Sometimes I get fucking envious of the people living in places like the Netherlands. There have been a few cases similar to mine, with less co-morbid conditions than I have, that were approved for euthanasia. (Mainly Jolanda Fun - but there were others)

Why do they get to go peacefully with dignity and I don't? Just because of where they were born. But I have to do this fucking shit. It pisses me off. Fuck humans - I hope the motherfuckers bomb each other to death. I hope they suffer.
 

Similar threads

JadedBeing
Replies
15
Views
661
Offtopic
ilovepsyschonaut4
ilovepsyschonaut4
B
Replies
0
Views
150
Suicide Discussion
bro2089
B
G
Replies
9
Views
693
Suicide Discussion
Ashes of a Dreamer
Ashes of a Dreamer
F
Replies
3
Views
301
Suicide Discussion
Foreverever
F